ROLLING STONES
- CD
ALTAMONT FESTIVAL
LABEL: |
Tarantura TCDALT-1,2/TCDRS-5 1-1,2/TCDRS-5 2-1,2 |
SOURCE: |
Altamont Raceway, Livermore Speedway Dec.6th 1969, Disc Six, Tracks 1 (from 6.55 on)-5 (up to 5.35),6 (up to 2.25 minutes),7: Musicorama Europe 1 broadcast, Dec.69. |
FORMAT: |
6 picture cds |
RUNNING TIME: |
77.35/78.56/47.50/34.01/48.17/38.42. |
SOUND/SOURCE: |
Disc One, Disc Two, Tracks 1-6, 11-23, Disc Three, Tracks 1,7 (from 2.00 on): Audience mono, Disc Two, Tracks 7-10, Disc Three, Tracks 2-16, Discs Five and Six, Track 1 (up to 6.55 minutes) and Track 5 (from 5.35 through the end) and Track 6 (from 2.25 on): Audience stereo, Disc Six, Tracks 1 (from 6.55 on)-5 (up to 5.35),6 (up to 2.25 minutes),7: Soundboard mono. Taper: George B. Feist (Duke) Produced by Zero Fighter at Pignosis |
PACKAGING: |
Cardboard box holding 6 pages photo book and three 2-discs sets with own gatefold covers. Lim. Edition of 100 numbered copies |
|
|
|
|
SOUND 9.5 / PACKAGING 7
/ PERFORMANCE 9
|
|
TRACK LIST: |
Disc One,
Part One, The Day Begins: 1. Radio Report, 2. Report, 3. Doug McKechnie Plays
The Moog Synthesizer, 4. Report, 5. Announcement, 6. Report, 7. Announcement, 8.
Radio Report, 9. Report, 10. Announcement, Santana: 11. Introduction, 12.
Savour, 13. Jingo, 14. Evil Ways, 15. Conquistador Rides Again, 16. Soul
Sacrifice, 17. Soul Sacrifice (continued), 18. Percussion Solo, 19. Soul Sacrifice
(continued), 20. Violence Interrupt, 21. Soul Sacrifice (continued), 22. Gumbo
(cut).
Disc Two, Part
Two, Omnibus Disc, Flying Burrito Brothers: 1. Six Days On The Road, 2. High
Fashion Queen, 3. Cody Cody, 4. Lazy Days, 5. Close Up The Honky Tonk, 6. Sweet
Mental Revenge (Mehtal on cover),
Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young: 7. Black Queen, 8. Pre-Road Downs, 9.
Long Time Gone, 10. Down By The River, Jefferson Airplane, 11. Sam Cutler s
Announcements And Introduction, 12. We Can Be Together, 13. Somebody To Love,
14. The Other Side Of This Life, 15. Violence Interrupts, 16. The Other Side Of
This Life, 17. Hells Angels Confrontation, 18. Sam Cutler Intervenes, 19. 3/5
Of A Mile In 10 Seconds, 20. Greasy Heart, 21. White Rabbit, 22. Come Back Baby
(cut), 23. The Ballad Of You And Me And Pooneil.
Disc Three,
Duke Audience Plus Radio Checked, Version One Rolling Stones: 1. MC, 2. Jumping
Jack Flash, 3. Carol, 4. Sympathy For The Devil False Start, 5. Stage
Chaos/Announcements, 6. Sympathy For The Devil, 7. Stage Announcements/Chaos,
8. The Sun Is Shining, 9. Stray Cat Blues, 10. Love In Vain, 11. Announcements,
12. Under My Thumb, 13. Announcements, 14. Under My Thumb, 15. MC, 16. Brown
Sugar.
Disc Four:
1. Midnight Rambler, 2. Live With Me, 3. Gimme Shelter, 4. Little Queenie, 5.
Satisfaction, 6. Honky Tonk Women, 7. Street Fighting Man.
Disc Five,
Duke Audience Plus Radio Checked, Version Two Rolling Stones: 1. MC, 2. Jumping
Jack Flash, 3. Carol, 4. Sympathy For The Devil False Start, 5. Stage
Chaos/Announcements, 6. Sympathy For The Devil, 7. Stage Announcements/Chaos,
8. The Sun Is Shining, 9. Stray Cat Blues, 10. Love In Vain, 11. Announcements,
12. Under My Thumb, 13. Announcements, 14. Under My Thumb, 15. MC, 16. Brown
Sugar.
Disc Six:
1. Midnight Rambler, 2. Live With Me, 3. Gimme Shelter, 4. Little Queenie, 5.
Satisfaction, 6. Honky Tonk Women, 7. Street Fighting Man.
|
|
|
REVIEW: |
This set was
due to present the 50th Anniversary of the Altamont event and was
planned to come out in December 2019 to commemorate it as the box back artwork clearly
indicates (Alt. Dec.2019 Tarantura) however, due to unknown reasons it came out
in May 2020.
The concept
brings to the mind Altamont Free Concert 1969 (IMP N-030) that came out in 2011
for Altamont s 40th Anniversary presenting on the first disc other
bands stereo audience recordings, Disc Two and part of Disc Three the Stones
performance from a 2 sources mix, then some tracks that come from a different
source and others that have been broadcasted on radio taken from an audience
source with the bonus of original taper explaining what happened when he was
recording; recently another box as released and reviewed here called Altamont
The End of an Era which included audio copy of Newsnight 69 that presented
songs excerpts in mono soundboard quality and a DVD itself included on Altamont
40th Anniversary called
Altamont Was The Nightmare (IMP N-030). This release seems an expanded
edition of the IMP release presenting all the bands that played that night on a
2 cd set as well as 2 versions of the Stones performance, everything taken from
the recording done by Duke of the whole festival which has finally surfaced in complete
uncut form and allegedly as a 1st generation recording. It is still
puzzling how on earth he managed to tape the whole festival without losing
power, he may have had a significant amount of extra batteries on hand. It has
also to be noted the taper s position which must have been quite close to the
PA system as the sound output is excellent.
The first disc
has original taper George B. Feist (Duke) reporting in excellent quality with live
comments from Altamont from the early morning hours of December 6th,
1969 which include the moog sounds played by Doug McKechnie, a strange
character who came to support the electronics being set up with the promise he
would have been allowed to play his synthesizer moog (the first ever portable
one) to the attending audience. The report continues with the reporter reaching
the stage at about 100 yards distance; then we can hear Sam Cutler addressing
the audience way before the concert begins asking people to get down from the scaffoldings
and not obstruct the way for possible ambulance cars. Other stage announcements
to ask people to move away from front stage and to ask people that got lost to
come to an igloo looking structure far away from the stage. The report
continues with the reporter mentioning an approximate audience of 200.000
people attending the festival as well as the first announcement of Santana
taking the stage; often we can hear Duke s comment (outstanding) following a
live performance and luckily not in the middle of a song. Trouble happens
during Soul Sacrifice which is interrupted by Santana due to violence on stage,
the last song Gumbo is cut and fades out. Surprisingly from Track 7 of Disc Two
(Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young) the source becomes stereo, making us assume
that previous tracks were unbalanced so that it was preferred by the label to
present them in mono, like the Jefferson Airplane tracks. Right through the Airplane
set violence erupted, as shown in the Gimme Shelter film, however Sam Cutler
intervenes asking everybody but the musicians and 2 of the road managers to
leave the stage; he mentions also the Grateful Dead road manager being on stage
at the time, meaning that up till then that band was convinced to play, what
happened next may have let them change their mind about that. The Ballad Of Me
And You And Pooneil is reported on the inside sleeve but not on the box back
cover tracking list, missing are The Fat Angel and Volunteers. Discs Three and
Four present version one of the Stones set, it starts with Sam Cutler
announcement in mono but then from Jumping Jack Flash on it is a stereo
recording. Amazingly Brown Sugar is not cut at the end, something that has
always been missing so far in the other stereo audience source of this concert;
by the way this being the very first live playing of this song that has the
best ever Keith Richards opening riff of the song ever played live. Naturally
this recording is far from perfect as many times, due to stage issues, the
microphone was not pointing at the PA system and thus we hear muffled sounds,
however it is a great document of this eventful day. The title of this set (as
of the next set, the only difference being version number) is Duke audience
plus radio air checked (probably meaning airchecks), which according to Wikipedia
are those recorded off-the-air by listeners, using consumer or
semi-professional equipment; these airchecks became more common with the advent
of commercial cassette recorders and we can assume that the checks are taper s
comments that have been included here to offer the most comprehensive document
possible; but Version Two discs are longer than Version One counterparts, the first
disc source is stereo and presents the longest audience recording of this
concert, making one suppose that Version One was issued before and disseminated
with some cuts, but this is a great wide stereo recording never heard before that
is a joy to listen to; there are also more between songs and audience comments
with regards to Version One that seems to have been edited or just missing some
recording. However, on Midnight Rambler around 6.55 minutes there is a patch
with another inferior (mono) soundboard source to complete the song; same thing,
but reversed, happens on Satisfaction where the radio broadcast is supplement
by a 2 minute stereo audience and on Honky Tonk Women (from around 2.25
minutes). The radio broadcast was Musicorama from Europe 1, a French AM broadcast,
which lasts through the end of the disc; this was already issued on Altamont (DAC
019) but here is in better quality. Personally I d like to hear the whole
unedited audience recording betetr, so Disc Five followed by Disc Four presents
the clearest image of that fateful night s event.
Packaging is hard to rate, the discs have nice pictures on
and each 2 cd set is housed in great picture gatefold sleeves, however the 6
pages booklet is pretty useless with b&w shots and absolutely nothing on
the box audio content, the tracklisting of which misses one song and overall
there is lack of information on the content. In fact from a look at it, it is
impossible to discern why there are 2 versions
of the same sound source, let alone the grammar mistakes as well as
wrong timings (it would seem from the gatefold covers info that the 2 Stones
versions are of the same length, untrue); a small marketing course could help.
So, i
s this
box the definitive Altamont recording? Probably not, if we think of the whole
raw soundboard that allegedly is around and from which some song comes out once
in a while (last one was Midnight Rambler), if ever Sam Cutler will decide to
release it; meanwhile this is the best alternative to that, too bad the whole
set was just printed in a 100 copies limited edition whose stock seems to be
down to 8 copies available as of now.
|
|
The best toys are the ones that are both educational and multi-purposeful.
Great Toys For Tots
Don't miss our new Top Vinyl List of the Departed
you’ll find something to tickle your fancy and your ears
Jun 11, 2020 - 12:57:16 PM
|