ROLLING STONES - CD
SILVER LINING

LABEL:
DAC 208
SOURCE:
Disc One: Track 1: Olympic St. London July 67, overdubs Olympic St. London 3 Oct.67, Track 2: Olympic St. London Feb.-March 69, Track 3: Olympic St. London 23 Apr.69, Track 4: Olympic St. London 6 June-7 July 70, Track 5: Olympic St. London Oct.70, reworked in Autumn 2009 at One East St., NY, Henson Rec. St. LA, The Village, LA, Mix This! LA and unknown St. London, Track 6: Dynamic Sound St. Kingston Nob.-Dec.72 overdubs at Island Rec. St. London May-June 73, Tracks 7,8: Island Rec. St. London May 73, Track 9: The Wick, Richmond London 4-6 Dec.73, Track 10: Record Plant St. L.A. late Dec.73, Track 11: Musicland St. Munich 8 Feb.74, Tracks 13: Musicland, Munich Feb.74 with vocal overdubs Don Was St. L.A. Jan.-Apr. 94, Track 13: The Wick, Richmond London 4 Oct.74 vocal overdubs Island Rec. St. London Oct.74, Track 14: Mobile St., Rotterdam 6-9 Feb.75, Tracks 15-17: Pathe Marconi St. Paris 10 Oct.-Dec.77. Disc Two, Track 1: Pathe Marconi St. Paris 10 Oct.-Dec.77, Track 2: RCA St. L.A. 5 Sep.78, Tracks 3,6: Compass Point, Nassau Jan.-Feb 79, overdubs Pathe Marconi St. Paris Nov.82, Tracks 4,5: Compass Point, Nassau Jan.-Feb.79, Track 7: Pathe Marconi St. Paris June-Oct.79, Tracks 8-15: Pathe Marconi St. Paris 11Nov.-19 Dec.82, overdubs Hit Factory N.Y. June-Aug.83, Track 16: Compass Point St., Nassau & Hit Factory N.Y. Apr.-1 Aug.83. Disc Three, Track 1: Pathe Marconi St. Paris Nov.-Dec.82, Tracks 2,3: Pathe Marconi St.Paris Jan.-Feb.85, Tracks 4-6: Pathe Marconi St. Paris May 85, overdubs RPM Sy. N.Y. July-Aug.85, Track 7: RPM St. N.Y. July-Aug.85, Track 8: RPM St., N.Y. July-Aug.85, vocal overdubs Guillame Tell St. Paris May-June 2002, Track 9: Air St. Montserrat Apr.89, Tracks 10,11: Sandymount St. Ireland Sept.93, vocal overdubs Windmill Lane St., Dublin 3 Nov.-11 Dec.93, Track 12: Sandymount St. Ireland July-Aug. 93,Track 13: Blue Wave St. Barbados Apr.-May 93. Disc Four, Tracks 1-12: Ocean Way Rec. St. L.A. 13 Mar-July 97, Tracks 13,14: Guillaume Tell St., Suresnes Paris 13 May-7 June 2002.
FORMAT:
4 cds
RUNNING TIME:
77.14/78.59/75.06/70.44
SOUND/SOURCE:
Soundboard Stereo mp3 sourced., except for Disc One, Tracks 7,8: Soundboard stereo
PACKAGING:
Fayboy case
 


***image2***

SOUND 10 / PACKAGING 8.5 / PERFORMANCE 10

 
TRACK LIST:

Disc One: 1. She’s Doing Her Thing, 2. Blood Red Wine, 3. Curtis Meets Smokey, 3. Walk With Me Wendy, 5. Tell Her How It Is, 6. Criss Cross, 7. 100 Years Ago, 8. Can’t You Hear The Music, 9. It’s Only Rock n Roll (But I Like It), 10. Too Many Cooks, 11. Fast Talking Slow Walking, 12. Living In The Heart Of Love, 13. Scarlet, 14. Built That Way,15. Never Make You Cry, 16. Fiji Jim, 17. Every Time I Break Her Heart.

Disc Two: 1. You Win Again, 2. Not The Way To Go, 3. Part Of The Night, 4. Trouble’s A Coming, 5. Covered In Bruises, 6. Can’t Find Love, 7. It’s A Lie, 8. (You Better) Stop That, 9. I’ve Got Dreams To Remember, 10. I Tried To Talk Her Into It, 1. Keep It Cool, 12. Cooking Up, 13. Eliza Upchink, 14. Still In Love With You, 15. Big Truff, 16. Undercover Of The Night.

Disc Three: 1. Keep It Cool. 2. Ronnie’s Song, 3. Don’t Lie To Me, 4. Strictly Memphis, 5. Putty In Your Hands, 6. Deep Love, 7. I Can’t See No One Else, 8. Nobody’s Perfect, 9. Giving It Up, 10. Ivy League, 11. Hands Off, 12. You Got Me Rocking, 13. Do Not Want Somebody Else.

Disc Four: 1. Might As Well Get Juiced, 2. Low Down, 3. Saint Of Me, 4. 20 Nil, 5. Flip The Switch, 6. Desperate Man, 7. Prairie Love, 8. Low Down, 9. Might As Well Get Juiced, 10. Too Tight, 11. Sanctuary, 12. Dream About, 13. Extreme Western Grip, 14. Well Well.    

 

 
REVIEW:

Here is DAC version of the recently surfaced Stones outtakes batches, the good news is that they are all found on this set, the bad news that they are still mp3 sourced.

However, on their ads for this release the label claimed it came from tracks ‘carefully corrected by fans’ a hint that it is a copy of Cpt Acid Remasters, where treble frequencies had been enhanced (Watts cymbals can be heard clearly now) and adding to that the known bias DAC has always had to boost the lower frequencies we get the best possible result so far. Here there are anyway 60 tracks, so apart from the 50 coming from the fully finished outtakes set, we have the 2 official songs that have appeared as bonus in the Japan edition of Goat’s Head Super Deluxe edition and the 7 new outtakes that leaked later, allegedly from Vinnie Karslake, Jo Wood’s brother in less brilliant shape. Having decided to present all these in chronological order these 7 takes are therefore positioned mostly in the Bridges to Babylon outtakes.

Disc Three Tracks 1 is a complete version of Keep It Cool, so now we shall examine the Keep It Cool saga. The first time this track appeared was version 1 which is the long one that starts with 2 count ins and lasts 20.57 (first posted by BKEYS on IORR, then on Foxes in the Boxes Vol.3 JEMS/WOW 123, the Virchov Tape (DAC 181) then on Undercover Complete Recording Sessions SBA 017, Undercover Definitive Recording Sessions Goldplate 1701, Undercover Sessions (Mayflower 135-8) The Art Collins Tapes & More EV 1288-89 and on The Incredible Art Collins Tapes Vol. 1 (DAC 200).

Version 2 the short one that clocked in at 9.54 on Foxes in the Boxes V.1 JEMS/WOW 12, then on a vinyl album of the same name by OBR 93036 and on silver disc on Undercover Complete Recording Sessions SBA 017 copied on Undercover Definitive Recording Sessions Goldplate 1701; then it appeared on Can’t Find Love (DAC 159) and on Art Collins Tapes & More EV 1288-89, Undercover Sessions (Mayflower 135-8) then on The Incredible Art Collins Tapes vol.1 (DAC 200). A slightly longer version 10.01 appeared on The Art Collins Tapes vol. 12-01 ending with drums as well as on the Incredible Art Collins Tapes Vol. 2 (DAC 201).

Version 3 lasts 5.24 and has finished with vocals and appeared on Fully Finished Outtakes Black Frisco Records 101-3 as well as on The Chronological Fully Finished Outtakes Acid Project Special.

Version 4 that can be found on Undercover Of The Night ZR lasting 27.05 is a fake looped version.

Version 5 was found on IORR, lasted 30.33 but ended with drums, contrary to

Version 6 which lasts 30.58 and was assembled by Cpt Acid who mixed 2 versions and can be found on The Art Collins Tapes & More (WLR AC 783).

Version 7 is this one which lasts 31.04 minutes according to the label, although the music stops again at 30.58 and the remaining seconds are dead air; this is called complete because it ends with the drums, although it seems to have been a Frankenstein operation too, just like the other three previous ones.

On this disc Track 4 (Strictly Memphis, has been patched adding the intro, having reversed channels; talking about editing, the noise sounds after Cooking Up and Flip The Switch have been removed.

Having examined the outtakes in previous reviews, it sounds pointless to re-do such work, although it must be stretched out that the so called Vinnie Karslake tracks were not part of Cpt. Acid Remasters. One stunning (in a negative sense) thing are front and back covers which show the band on stage in its latest years (Manchester 2018 and Lisbon 2014) which are completely out of context here; I haven’t rated as such the whole packaging because in fact the 2 inner sleeves with sources are precious and, although hard to read without a magnifying lens or a digital transfer, offer valuable information on overdubbing dates. All in all this is a valuable release and not just for late comers.


The best toys are the ones that are both educational and multi-purposeful.
Great Toys For Tots

 

Don't miss our new Top Vinyl List of the Departed
you’ll find something to tickle your fancy and your ears

 

ROLLING STONES

Latest Reviews

SIXTY NEW OUTTAKES
SOME GIRLS & TATTOO YOU REWORKED
LIVE ON DAVID FROST
IN PARIS 1970
LIVE AT THE OAKLAND COLISEUM
SILVER LINING
GLYN JOHNS MASTER REELS
WELCOME TO NEW YORK DELUXE
IN COLOR VOL.3
IN COLOR VOL.2

 

Jul 10, 2021 - 1:48:03 PM

Reviews Home 
 
  ARTIST R
  ROLLING STONES

RoboForm: Learn more...

Reviews Home 
 
  ARTIST A
 
  ARTIST B
 
  ARTIST C
 
  ARTIST D
 
  ARTIST E
 
  ARTIST F
 
  ARTIST G
 
  ARTIST H
 
  ARTIST I
 
  ARTIST J
 
  ARTIST K
 
  ARTIST L
 
  ARTIST M
 
  ARTIST N
 
  ARTIST O
 
  ARTIST P
 
  ARTIST Q
 
  ARTIST R
 
  ARTIST S
 
  ARTIST T
 
  ARTIST U
 
  ARTIST V
 
  ARTIST W
 
  ARTIST X
 
  ARTIST Y
 
  ARTIST Z

Copyright© HotWacks.com